Decompositions and Semantics

Introduction

In the context of semantic data processing, decomposition refers to the process of breaking down complex entities or systems into smaller, more manageable components. This approach facilitates a deeper understanding of the subject matter, enables more efficient analysis, and supports effective problem-solving.

Decomposition - A Definition

According to the Cambridge Dictionary, decomposition is “the action of breaking, or breaking something, into smaller parts.” In the context of information systems, it involves analyzing and dividing a whole into its constituent elements to understand their individual characteristics and relationships.

Benefits of Decomposition

  • Improved Understanding: By breaking down complex systems, we can gain a deeper understanding of their intricacies and underlying mechanisms.

  • Enhanced Problem-Solving: Decomposition enables systematic analysis and problem-solving by addressing complex issues in smaller, more manageable pieces.

Key Characteristics of Decompositions

  • Viewpoint-dependent: Decompositions are inherently subjective and created from a specific perspective.

  • Informal Nature: Unlike formal ontologies, decompositions are often less structured and more flexible.

Decomposition Examples

  • Project Management: Decomposing a project into tasks and sub-tasks.

  • Engineering: Dividing a complex system into subsystems, components, and sub-components and then into documents that contain the data about the components.

  • Business Processes: Breaking down a business process into individual steps and activities.

  • Shipping: Decomposing in break-bulk and container transport, then in ships (for break-bulk) and containers and packages.

The second and fourth example contain different ‘things’ on different levels. That is not a mistake. If a decomposition like this works for the users, it may be a very good solution. I hve personally worked for a company with a stable turnover in excess of 0.5B Euro, based all their work on this single decoposition. The important thing here is: decompositions serve those that use them and these are tailored to their needs, even if they’re against theory.

Decompositions vs. Ontologies/Taxonomies

While related, decompositions differ significantly from ontologies and taxonomies:

  • Ontologies: Formal representations of knowledge, emphasizing precise definitions and relationships between concepts (e.g., subclass, instance-of).

  • Taxonomies: Structured classifications of concepts based on hierarchical relationships (e.g., broader, narrower, related).

  • Decompositions: Focus on breaking down a whole into its constituent parts from a specific viewpoint, often less formal than ontologies or taxonomies.

Table of contents